Interview With Government Humanitarian Aid Commissioner on the Darfur Crisis

UN Integrated Regional Information Networks

INTERVIEW

April 7, 2004

Posted to the web April 7, 2004 Khartoum

Responding to international accusations that lawless militias have been committing serious human rights violations in the western region of Darfur, Dr Sulaf al-Din Salih, the commissioner-general of Sudan's Humanitarian Aid Commission, told IRIN that the international community was misinformed about the reality in Darfur. The accusations, he added during an interview in the capital, Khartoum, on 2 April, were part of a campaign against the Sudanese government and people. Below are excerpts:

Q: Since December 2003, the humanitarian situation in Darfur has reportedly got considerably worse. What has happened?

A: I don't consider that the situation has got considerably worse. On the contrary, I think the situation has really improved since then. Everyone knows this was triggered by a rebel attack on civilians, on government properties, on government projects. And it was quite a natural thing that the government authorities, as well as the local communities, started fighting back at the rebellion.

It peaked when many areas were not accessible. But now almost all areas, except for a limited area in the Jabal Marrah, are accessible. Now we have national and international NGOs placed in the area. We are encouraging local NGOs from Darfur, and they are making their own campaign for collecting donations and establishing their offices there.

Q: So humanitarian access is better now, but there are many reports that the situation on the ground is much worse.

A: It is not true, it is not true. And I'm quite sure, because we are in every village, we receive reports, and we follow up on the situation very well. There is no famine, there are still some attacks between different groups, bandits moving around, but definitely there are more police forces going to the area, more army to keep the security of the people in the field. So we think that things are improving quite a lot.

Q: The Janjawid [militias], plus the army, have been accused of ethnic cleansing or a scorched earth policy. Reports say the situation is getting worse and will continue. How do you respond to that?

A: We think this is a political campaign. Unfortunately, the UN office here in Sudan and worldwide has been part of this political campaign against the government. This is very serious - we are really considering an option of taking the UN out of the area. This is very serious because these statements are not true. This is false information, because they [the UN] don't have the ability to access all the areas. So now the UN office worldwide is producing data which is quite contrary to what is happening in the field. This has been used by many political groups against the government, against the whole peace process.

Q: It's not just the UN though. Other groups such as Human Rights Watch, groups that are very highly respected worldwide, are also reporting the same thing.

A: They are not in the field. We are having problems, yes. It has mounted into some sort of tribal conflict, but we are exerting the maximum effort from the government side to stop this. At first it was one group, a political rebellion, then it became a tribal conflict. But as I said, we have managed to get the fullest commitment from all the tribal leaders to stop this. This is one of the major projects for the government: to bring the social fabric back again.

Q: So the tribal leaders have committed [themselves] to stopping the violence. But do they control the Janjawid?

A: It is not only the Janjawid. People forget about the other groups called Tora Bora and others as well.

Definitely the government did not have enough forces to control all the area. So these groups have committed atrocities and have gone beyond the normal security or military operations. But it is the commitment of the government, and this has been raised by the president on all the committees, that everyone has to be under control of the army or the police.

I think we have succeeded in controlling all these groups to a very great extent. Up to now, there are still some activities, but far less than there used to be.

Q: There have been many accusations that the army is involved in the attacks, working alongside the militias. Do you accept that, and what is being done to stop it?

A: If there is any such claim, we want to know it so we can investigate. We know of some cases where things were brought to court. But we do welcome, really welcome, any specific cases so we can investigate.

Q: The last time we spoke in December, you talked about the fact that the government had supported the militias in an effort to fight the rebellion in Darfur, that it had called people forward to fight the rebels. A: We asked all the people of Darfur to help in protecting themselves against the rebellion. This is standard practice which we do in this country. Whenever there is an attack on a community, we ask the local community to support, to help.

Q: But we have a situation now where the same people are committing atrocities

A: Now the situation is largely under control by the armed forces, the police and local authorities. Also because of the involvement of local leaders, local chiefs in the peace process, there is a better humanitarian situation compared to the past. But I think that the international community should be fair and positive enough to state that it was the rebel groups which started attacking. They're the ones who ignited the whole problem in the area. And then it became a sort of catalytic [sic] thing, of people fighting back or defending themselves, or even going beyond defending themselves... We have a list of atrocities committed by the rebel groups - killing, raping, looting, destroying development projects. In South Darfur, they have been killing people inside hospitals - patients. So I think the international community should adopt a more balanced vision and approach to the problem.

Q: You mentioned there being more army and police enforcement in Darfur, and yet reports are still continuing of atrocities. What is being done to arrest or stop either the Janjawid or the rebels?

A: We have asked the judicial system there, the police and the army to take things into their hands, and for people to report to the police and to take cases to court so that everyone can raise their case in front of the judicial system.

It will take some time from our own experience, because we don't have many courts. It is the tribal system which is going to have the major role. These tribes have their own mechanisms of settling problems between themselves. They have their own systems of compensation, or recognition, and there are very major claims of looting of thousands of herds and killing of people.

Q: You keep coming back to the statement that the international community has a false impression of what is happening in Darfur. Why is this?

A: It is a campaign, a political campaign led by groups against the people of Sudan, the government of Sudan. This is an imbalance, it is not fair. Our position is the following: yes, we have a problem, we had a very serious problem in the past. We managed to control it in a reasonable way. Things are improving in terms of delivery of aid, of controlling atrocities.

But there are still some problems. We recognise this, we want the international community to help us to bypass and bring safety and security and reach some sort of an agreed solution to the problem. This problem did not start last year. They [people of Darfur] have had their own political concerns for more than 40 years. So now one of the decisions of the ministerial committee is to look in depth into the reasons for the grievances. I think this is a real challenge for us now, how we identify the reasons: marginalisation or an unbalanced approach to the area or whatever; but really we have to look at the root causes of the problem and try to tackle them.

Q: In the event of a ceasefire, what will be done to allow the hundreds of thousands of displaced people to go back to their homes?

A: People are already going back home. People have the ability to assess the situation, whether they can go back or not. This has been done through local mechanisms or tribal systems. They make an agreement between themselves that they are going to protect this process of return, that no one is going to attack them. So whether there is a ceasefire or not, this process has already started.

Q: Will the government be giving assurances to people that they can move back?

A: We are already giving these assurances to people. But as I have said, the people are making their own decisions. They have their own system of sensing whether it is safe or not to go back. We are trying to encourage it, but definitely it is their own decision. The state government, the local authorities, as well as the local chiefs, are helping them to make that decision. But it is quite a voluntary process

>> THE HUMANITARIAN CRISIS
Sudanese rebels urged to return vehicles seized from British charity
Two million Darfur children get Measles shot
WFP close to Darfur food aid deal with Libya
British lawmakers urge Europe, U.S. to do more for Darfur victims
Sudan accuses rebels of kidnapping aid workers in Darfur
Khartoum decrees end to restrictions on relief
Presidential Decrees to Facilitate Security and Relief in Darfur
Sudan draws up plan to get Darfur displaced back home
Sudan announces urgent plan for solving humanitarian situation in Darfur
U.S. and U.N. withhold 'genocide' tag for Sudan killings
Sudan to set up 18 "settlements" for million Darfur refugees: report
No Genocide in Darfur:
US Government
Annan urges political solution for Sudan's Darfur 'as soon as possible'
President al-Bashir Announces Lifting of Administrative Procedures for Humanitarian Assistance
Positive Progress in Humanitarian Situation Achieved, Says UN Representative
Sudan's govt accuses Darfur rebels of attacking FAO food convoy
WFP Scales Up Operations in Darfur, Aims to Feed 700,000 in June
UNHCR Now Operational in Darfur Region
Insecurity, lack of funds hit U.N. aid to Sudan
Key facts on international humanitarian assistance efforts in Darfur
Darfur Rebel Attack Stops Water Supply Project
Situation in Darfur Under Control: Minister
Sudan: Interview with Kevin Kennedy, Outgoing Acting UN Humanitarian Coordinator for Sudan
Donors Fail to Deliver for People of Darfur, Sudan
New Zealand provides more aid for Sudan
Germany grants 20m dollars in aid for W. Sudan
Sunday June 20th, 2004.
No genocide in Sudan, Annan says
UNHCR ups appeal for Sudan's Darfur to $56 mln
UNICEF to appeal for more funds for war-ravaged Darfur
UN OCHA Statement on detention and release of humanitarian workers in Darfur
EU to finance Darfur ceasefire mission
UNHCR revises budget for Chad operations to $55.8 million
Sudan relaxes travel restrictions
Rebels free aid workers in stricken Darfur
Sudan denies 'ethnic cleansing' after rights group makes allegations
Sudanese officials reject UN charges of ethnic cleansing in Darfur
Rebel group abducts 16 relief workers in Sudan's Darfur region Saturday
UN says detention of aid workers in Sudan "totally unacceptable"
U.N. says west Sudan rebels release aid workers
Norway grants 37.5 mill in humanitarian aid to Western Sudan
Sudan: Donor Meeting On Darfur Appeals for US $236 Million
Sudan says relief organizations can enter Darfur after notifying authorities
High-level UN meeting on Sudan's Darfur crisis kicks-off in Geneva
U.N. asks US$236 million to aid Sudanese in 'biggest humanitarian crisis'
E.U. pledges 10 million euro aid for Darfur war victims Thursday June 3rd, 2004.
UN and US warn that huge toll in Darfur crisis is now inevitable
10 Crucial Steps to Address Humanitarian Crisis in Darfur, Sudan
NGOs Active on the Darfur crisis
Rains in Chad Interrupt Refugee Transfers From Darfur, Sudan, UN Agency Says
World Must Boost Aid to Sudan, Chad Humanitarian Crisis - Geneva Donors' Meeting a Vital Opportunity
Sudan says relief organizations can enter Darfur after notifying authorities
UN says disease and death rising in Sudan's Darfur
Sudan govt, rebels agree to send international observers to Darfur
Humanitarian access blocked in Darfur
AU observers due in Sudan's Darfur region in next few days.
UN reaches hungry in Darfur
UN's Annan hails Sudan moves on Darfur aid.
Aid workers unable to reach most war zones in Darfur, western Sudan
Sudan rights body differs with reports on Darfur crisis
United Nations issues appeal for Darfur, Sudan
Khartoum cries for urgent relief aid in Darfur
Secretary-General welcomes Sudan's announcement of steps to facilitate humanitarian access to Darfur region
WFP confirms massive humanitarian crisis in Darfur, and calls the plight of Sudanese refugees "tragic"
Rebels, not government-backed militia, responsible for violence in W. Sudan: officials
Sudanese minister calls on international aid agencies to come Darfur
Humanitarian needs continue despite Darfur accord
Sudanese government to airlift relief to Darfur
United Nations confirms massive humanitarian crisis in Darfur and insists on improved security and access
Sudanese FM warns of dire humanitarian needs in Darfur after ceasefire
Sudan says it has sent new batch of relief aid to war-torn Darfur region
Khartoum Blames Darfur Rebels for Blocking Aid
Relief, rehabilitation call for western Sudan launched
UN envoy to discus humanitarian corridors from Chad with Sudanese authorities
Western Sudan too dangerous for road convoys
Sudan assures UN of commitment to development, relief in Darfur
Aid access improves to war-torn Darfur, says minister
UN : Sudan promises aid workers access to strife-ridden Darfur
Humanitarian access to Darfur still difficult : sources
Sudan says trying to secure access for relief to Darfur region
Interview With Government Humanitarian Aid Commissioner on the Darfur Crisis
Morris urges security, aid for Darfur refugees
Government, humanitarian agencies assessing conditions in Darfur
Humanitarian access blocked in Darfur
UN pushing for "humanitarian ceasefire" in Sudan's Darfur region
     
Darfur Information Published by The European - Sudanese Public Affairs Council Copyright © David Hoile 2005
powered by hypertools.co.uk